
-
Board Certified Criminal Trial Attorney
Joseph Patituce is one of the 13 board-certified specialists in Ohio state.
-
Over 70 Years of Combined Experience
Our Attorneys have taken cases to jury trials over 400 times.
-
No-Cost, Confidential Phone Consultations
Call for a free consultation, you will speak to an attorney immediately.

Toledo Criminal Defense Attorney
At Patituce & Associates, we’re committed to presenting your side of the story persuasively and effectively in court.
Our sole focus is on defending people who are facing criminal charges in Ohio. Our team consists of three former Cuyahoga County prosecutors who are now dedicated to protecting the rights and interests of the accused.
Collectively, we have won thousands of cases and successfully navigated more than 200 criminal trials. Our Toledo criminal defense attorneys know the challenges our clients face as they confront the charges against them and aggressively explore every conceivable legal avenue toward a reduction or dismissal on their behalf.
Contact us for a free initial consultation with a Toledo criminal defense attorney at Patituce & Associates by calling (440) 771-1175 today.
-
How soon should I hire a defense attorney after being arrested?
Engaging a defense attorney promptly after an arrest is of paramount importance. The period immediately following an arrest is often filled with critical moments that can significantly influence the trajectory of a case. Having an attorney early on ensures that your rights are protected from the outset and that you can avoid certain pitfalls, such as self-incrimination during police interrogations. Your interests are paramount to us; as soon as you contact an attorney, we begin to take charge of your case by starting the process of building a robust defense strategy. Early legal intervention can also impact bail considerations, evidence preservation, and witness testimonies. In essence, the sooner you have a defense attorney advocating for you, the better positioned you’ll be to navigate the complexities of the criminal justice system.
-
How often will I be updated about my case’s progress?
At our firm, transparency, and communication are cornerstones of our client relationships. We understand that facing criminal charges can be a distressing, uncertain experience. Therefore, we commit to providing regular updates at critical junctures of your case, whether that’s pre-trial hearings, negotiations, or changes in case strategy.
Beyond these systematic updates, we foster an open line of communication where our clients are encouraged to reach out anytime they have concerns, questions, or require clarifications. Our aim is to ensure you’re always informed and empowered throughout the legal process.
-
What is a plea bargain, and how does it work?
A plea bargain is a negotiated agreement between the defendant’s attorney and the prosecution. This agreement typically involves the defendant agreeing to plead guilty to a lesser charge or to one of multiple charges in exchange for a reduced sentence, the dismissal of other charges, or other concessions from the state.
The plea bargain process can be intricate. It often involves weighing the strength of the evidence, the potential penalties if convicted at trial, and the specific circumstances of the defendant. While plea bargains can expedite the legal process and provide a certain outcome, they also require the defendant to relinquish their right to a trial. It’s crucial to work closely with an experienced Toledo criminal defense attorney who can provide guidance on whether accepting a plea offer is in the defendant’s best interests.
-
What is the difference between a misdemeanor and a felony in Ohio?
In Ohio, both misdemeanors and felonies represent categories of crimes, but they differ primarily in terms of severity, potential penalties, and long-term consequences.
Misdemeanors are less severe criminal offenses, though they still carry significant consequences. Ohio classifies misdemeanors into five degrees, with the first being the most severe and the fifth being the least. For example, a first-degree misdemeanor might involve offenses like petty theft or certain DUI offenses, resulting in penalties of up to 6 months in county jail and fines up to $1,000. Conversely, fifth-degree misdemeanors are less severe and might result in smaller fines and less jail time.
Felonies are more serious offenses and carry stiffer penalties. Ohio categorizes felonies into five degrees as well, with the first degree being the most serious and the fifth degree being the least in terms of felonies. A first-degree felony, for instance, might pertain to crimes like aggravated robbery or attempted murder and could lead to penalties ranging from 3 to 11 years in prison and hefty fines. Fifth-degree felonies, although less severe than first-degree, still carry considerable penalties, which can include prison time.
In addition to immediate penalties, the distinction between a misdemeanor and a felony has long-term implications. A felony conviction can significantly impact an individual’s ability to find employment, housing, or even obtain certain licenses. It also affects one’s voting rights and ability to possess firearms.
Given the gravity of these consequences, it’s crucial to consult with a legal professional if facing either type of charge in Ohio, as the legal nuances and potential consequences can be complex and profoundly impact one’s life.

-
State v. Steve Gue Reduced Sentence
RECKLESS HOMICIDE
Client was charged with reckless homicide.
-
State v. Tevin Biles Acquittal
TRIPLE MURDER/FELONIOUS ASSAULT
Client was identified as one of the alleged shooters at a New Year’s Eve party.
-
State v. Beckwith, Cuyahoga County Charges Dismissed
DRUG TRAFFICKING
Student charged with the manufacturing of ecstasy.
-
STATE V. BAILEY, CUYAHOGA Plea and Record Expunged
AGGRAVATED THEFT
Client was accused of stealing tens of thousands of dollars worth of property.
-
STATE V. BOSCARELLO, CUYAHOGA COUNTY Significant Reduction, Probation
AGGRAVATED BURGLARY
Client accused of high-level felonies of violence.
-
STATE V. J.S. (A JUVENILE) YOUNGSTOWN Case Dismissed
CHILD PORNOGRAPHY
Local counsel pushed for a plea to one of the sex related charges.
-
ROCKY RIVER V. D.F. Not Guilty At Trial
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
Client was charged with domestic violence against his wife.
-
STATE V. BITTNER, LORAIN COUNTY Charges Dismissed
DRUG TRAFFICKING
Client caught selling drugs.
-
CITY OF CLEVELAND V. OLES Evidence Suppressed State Lost the Appeal
DUI/OVI
Client was stopped for what a trooper described as being an illegal lane change.
-
CLEVELAND V. AL-NAZER (2012 TRC 040781) Case Dismissed
DUI/OVI
Our client was accused of driving while under the influence of drugs, or alcohol.
-
STATE V. AL-NAZER (CUYAHOGA CASE NO. 13-575491) Case Dismissed
DUI/OVI W. A WEAPON
The trooper in this case went to every possible step to obtain a conviction against our client but we fought for him.
-
BAY VILLAGE V. CRIDER Case Dismissed
DUI/OVI
Client was accused of operating a motor vehicle while impaired.
-
CITY OF OBERLIN V. BARBER OVI Charges Dismissed
DUI/OVI
Client, a young adult, was pulled over for speeding.
-
U.S. V. BREHUN Client Received House Arrest and Probation
FEDERAL BANKRUPTCY FRAUD
Client charged with bankruptcy fraud.
-
U.S. V. MUKUNDKUMAR Client Received a One Year Sentence
FEDERAL BRIBERY CHARGERS
Client charged with bribing a city official and faced a significant prison sentence.
-
U.S. V. POLING Client Only Received a Five Year Sentence
FEDERAL CHILD PORNOGRAPHY CHARGES
-
UNITED STATES V. WILLIAMS Sentenced Under the Mandatory Minimum Sentence
FEDERAL DRUG CHARGES
Client faced a mandatory minimum of ten years in prison with a federal sentencing guideline range of nearly 20 years.
-
U.S. V. LOVE Massively Reduced Sentence
FEDERAL DRUG TRAFFICKING/MONEY LAUNDERING
Client charged with assisting boyfriend in the operation of a multistate drug operation. Faced in excess of ten years in prison.
-
STATE V. BRANDON BETLISKEY Not Guilty at Trial
FELONIOUS ASSAULT/ATTEMPTED MURDER
Client was accused with attempted murder and felonious assault for stabbing an individual with a knife during a fight.
-
STATE V. MICHAEL ZEINER Not Guilty at Trial, Finding of Self-Defense
FELONIOUS ASSAULT
Michael Zeiner was initially charged with felonious assault, a felony of the second degree under Ohio law.
-
STATE V. BAILEY Felonies Reduced to a Misdemeanor
FRAUD
Client faced over five years in prison relating to fraud coming from purchases on certain credit cards.
-
STATE V. BANKSTON (CASE 554763) Felonies Reduced to a Misdemeanor
MORTGAGE FRAUD
Client charged in a massive mortgage fraud operation by the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor’s office.
-
CITY OF CLEVELAND V. OLES Evidence Suppressed
OVI-APPEAL
After our victory in the trial court the City of Cleveland appealed this case to the 8 th District Court of Appeals.
-
BAY VILLAGE V. KELLER Prosecutor Dismissed the OVI Charges
OVI
-
STATE V. MITCHELL, AKRON Plead to Reduced Charges and Avoided Prison
OVI
-
STATE V. SHAVER, ELYRIA Reduction in Charges and Client Avoided Mandator
OVI
-
STATE V. BANKS, PORT CLINTON No Charges
RAPE
-
STATE V. BUXO, CUYAHOGA COUNTY All Sex Counts Dismissed, Probation
RAPE
-
STATE V. CALLAWAY, ZAINESVILLE Not Guilty on All Felony Sex Offenses
RAPE
-
STATE V. J. SMITH, CUYAHOGA COUNTY Rape Allegation Dismissed
RAPE
-
STATE V. KING Felonies Dismissed
RAPE
Client was involved in a situation with another person his age.
-
STATE V. KING, CUYAHOGA COUNTY Charges Dismissed, Reduced to Misdemeanor
RAPE
Client drank too much with a female companion at a party – both were under 21.
-
STATE V. MCCLINTICK, PORTAGE COUNTY Case Dismissed
RAPE
Client drank too much with a female companion at a party – both were under 21.
-
STATE V. MCCLINTICK, PORTAGE COUNTY Case Dismissed
RAPE
Hired to replace local counsel.
-
STATE V. LEVANDUSKI Dismissed
OVI
-
UNITED STATES V. PUGH, 1:16-CR-00291-BYP. Sentence Reduced to 55 Months
INTENT TO DISTRIBUTE
Client faced possession with intent to distribute LSD 21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1) and 841(b)(1)(A).
-
Unindicted
FEDERAL ANALOGUE DRUG CHARGES
-
Unindicted
FEDERAL ANALOGUE DRUG CHARGES
Why Hire Our Criminal Attorneys in Toledo?
At Patituce & Associates, our team is committed to a personalized approach to criminal defense. We learn the stories behind each of our clients, what their unique circumstances are, and what their goals are as they face the accusations against them.
This has allowed us to build relationships with our clients and their families and ensure we effectively and thoroughly advocate for them during this uncertain time. Clients throughout the Toledo area choose us for several reasons, including:
- Over 70 years of combined experience
- 1,000s of criminal defense cases won
- Successfully handled over 200 jury trials including murder trial acquittals
- Being the law firm other attorneys, police, and prosecutors turn to for help
- Our lead attorney is a Board Certified Criminal Trial Attorney
- Offering no-cost, confidential phone consultations and are available 24/7
Ready to start exploring your legal options? We’re ready to hear from you. Contact our Toledo criminal defense lawyers at (440) 771-1175 today.


Benefits of Hiring an Ohio Criminal Defense Attorney
When you have been charged with a crime, hiring a criminal defense attorney in Ohio is one of the most important decisions you can make. A defense attorney with experience handling similar cases to yours can help protect your rights and your future. Below are just some of the benefits of hiring a Cleveland criminal defense attorney:
-
Knowledge of the Legal System
-
Protection of Your Rights
-
Development of a Strong Defense Strategy
-
Mitigation of Potential Consequences

Battle-Tested Criminal Attorneys Handling All Types of Cases
Being accused of or charged with a crime is, without question, a legal emergency. Depending upon your circumstances and the severity of the charges, your reputation, career, family life, and freedom may hang in the balance.
With so much at stake, you need an experienced attorney at your side. At Patituce & Associates, we have the experience, knowledge, and resources to help you mount the strongest possible defense. We understand how important your case is and always dedicate the time and effort necessary to achieve the greatest outcome.
We take pride in that we are known for their fierce advocacy and rigorous defense of the Constitution. Our firm is well-versed in cases that involve felony and misdemeanor offenses, including federal crimes.
We can help you with the following types of cases:
- Arson
- Assault
- Casino Offenses
- Child Enticement
- Coercion
- Criminal Mischief
- Criminal Usury
- DUI/OVI
- Domestic Violence
- Drug Crimes
- Extortion
- Family Crimes
- Federal Crimes
- Homicide
- Juvenile Crimes
- Kidnapping & Human Trafficking
- Medical Disciplinary Action
- Post-Conviction
- Sex Crimes
- Violent Crimes
- Theft Crimes
- Vandalism
- Weapons Crimes
- White Collar Crimes

client testimonials HEAR HOW WE'VE MADE A DIFFERENCE
-
“I couldn't have made a better choice.”
- Glenn G.I engaged Joe Patituce's services for my DUI case in Rocky River, and I couldn't have made a better choice. He and his team demonstrated excellence throughout, managing my case with remarkable skill and professionalism.
There is no case that is hopeless What to Look for in an Ohio Criminal Defense Lawyer
If your freedom is on the line, our attorneys will fight for you.
Choosing the right Ohio criminal defense attorney can mean the difference between
a successful outcome or a conviction with serious consequences. When looking for
an Ohio criminal defense lawyer, there are several factors you should consider. With
the right attorney by your side, you can have confidence in your case and increase
your chances of achieving the best possible outcome. At Patituce & Associates,
LLC, our attorneys bring a wealth of experience, knowledge, and resources to the
table. Coupled with an impressive record of successful verdicts, our lawyers have
the skills and expertise necessary to help you navigate the Ohio criminal justice system.
-
Has Experience Handling Cases Similar to YoursCriminal law is complex, and a firm that focuses its practice on criminal defense will have a better understanding of the laws and strategies that can help you achieve the best outcome. Your lawyer should be familiar with the court system and judges in the area and have a track record of success in obtaining positive results for their clients.
-
Board Certified Criminal Trial Attorney
Joseph Patituce is one of the 13 board-certified specialists in Ohio state.
-
- Joseph Patituce | Founder & Partner
"The practice of criminal law is at the heart of what happens every day in our society. I started practicing criminal law as a way of helping people obtain justice for themselves and their families."
We Serve all of Toledo and Surrounding Areas
Our Toledo criminal defense law firm is located at 412 14th St., Toledo, OH, 44331. If you have a legal matter to discuss with us in the greater northern Ohio area, please contact us at a location that’s convenient for you.
In addition, we serve the following neighborhoods within Toledo:
- Birmingham
- East Toledo
- Franklin Park
- Old West End
- DeVeaux
- Westgate
- Ottawa
- Point Place
- South Side
- Scott Park
- Five Points
- Reynolds Corners
- Beverly
- Warehouse District
- North River
Call (440) 771-1175 or fill out our contact form to request your free, confidential case evaluation today.

Joseph Patituce is one of the 13 board-certified specialists in Ohio state.

