Will I Go to Jail for Theft?

Theft is a serious crime that can lead to severe consequences, including jail time. If you face accusations of theft, you may wonder about the potential consequences and whether you will end up behind bars.

The best way to know about the potential consequences you face and how you might stay out of jail is to consult a theft defense lawyer immediately.

Schedule A Free Consultation

Understanding Theft Charges

Theft is the unlawful taking of someone else’s property without their consent, intending to permanently deprive them of it. There are different types of theft, including:

Petty Theft

Petty theft is a criminal offense that involves stealing property with a relatively low value. The specific dollar amount distinguishing petty theft from grand theft varies by state law. In some states, the threshold for petty theft may be as low as $500, while in others, it may be $1,000 or more.

Petty theft is often considered a misdemeanor offense, which carries less severe penalties than felony crimes. However, the consequences of a petty theft conviction can still be significant, including fines, probation, and even short periods of jail time.

Examples of petty theft include:

• Shoplifting small items from a store.
• Stealing a bicycle from someone’s yard.
• Taking a phone that was left unattended in a public place.

While these may seem minor offenses, they can still result in criminal charges and have a lasting impact on a person’s record.

Grand Theft

Grand theft is a more serious criminal offense than petty theft. It involves stealing property with a higher value. The exact dollar amount that constitutes grand theft varies by state, but it is typically a felony offense.

In some states, grand theft may further subdivide into different degrees based on the value of the stolen property. For example, theft of property worth $1,000 to $20,000 may be considered grand theft in the third degree, while theft of property worth $100,000 or more may be grand theft in the first degree.

The penalties for grand theft are generally more severe than petty theft and may include significant fines, lengthy probation, and even prison time. The specific sentence will depend on the circumstances of the case, the defendant‘s criminal history, and other factors.

Examples of grand theft include:

• Stealing a car.
• Embezzling large sums of money from an employer.
• Stealing high-value jewelry or artwork.

Shoplifting

Shoplifting is theft involving stealing merchandise from a store or other retail establishment. It is a common form of petty theft but can also be charged as grand theft if the value of the stolen goods exceeds the state’s threshold.

Shoplifting can take many forms, including concealing items in bags or clothing, switching price tags for a lower price, or simply walking out of the store without paying for the merchandise. Retailers often use security measures such as cameras, sensors, and loss prevention personnel to deter and detect shoplifting.

In addition to criminal penalties, those caught shoplifting may face civil consequences, such as being banned from the store or being required to pay restitution for the stolen goods. Repeat offenders may face enhanced criminal charges and more severe penalties.

Burglary

Burglary is a criminal offense that involves entering a building or structure intending to commit a crime inside, such as theft or assault. It is a more serious offense than simple theft because it involves the additional element of unlawful entry.

In many states, burglary is a felony offense, with penalties that may include significant fines and lengthy prison sentences. The specific sentence will depend on whether the building was occupied during the offense, whether any weapons were involved, and the defendant’s criminal history.

Burglary can take many forms, from breaking into a home, stealing valuables, entering a commercial building after hours, or committing theft or vandalism. It is a serious crime that can have a profound impact on victims, both financially and emotionally.

Robbery

A robbery is a violent form of theft that involves the use of force, threats, or intimidation to take property from another person. It is a more serious offense than simple theft because it involves the additional element of violence or the threat of violence.

Robbery can take many forms, from mugging someone on the street to holding up a bank with a weapon. It is a felony offense in all states, with penalties that may include lengthy prison sentences and significant fines.

The specific sentence for robbery will depend on factors such as the use of a weapon, the extent of any injuries to the victim, and the defendant’s criminal history. In some cases, authorities may charge robbery as armed robbery or aggravated robbery, resulting in even more severe penalties.

Factors That Affect Sentencing

When determining the appropriate sentence for a theft conviction, judges consider various factors, such as:

• The Value of the Stolen Property: Higher-value thefts result in more severe penalties.
• The Defendant’s Criminal History: A defendant with a prior criminal record, especially theft-related, may face harsher sentences.
• The Circumstances of the Theft: The court will consider the specific details of the theft, such as whether it was premeditated or committed under duress.
• The Victim’s Impact: The court may consider the impact of the theft on the victim, such as financial hardship or emotional distress.
• The Defendant’s Remorse and Cooperation: Showing genuine remorse and cooperating with the authorities may lead to a more lenient sentence.

Defenses Against Theft Charges

The court may impose probation on the defendant, involving supervision and adherence to specific conditions. Some common defenses include:

Lack of Intent

In theft cases, the prosecution must prove that the defendant intended to permanently deprive the owner of their property. If the defendant can show that they did not have this intent, it may serve as a defense against the theft charges.

For example, if a person borrowed an item from a friend with the genuine intention of returning it but then forgot to do so or lost the item, they can argue that they lacked the intent to steal. Similarly, if someone took an item by mistake, believing it to be their own, they may have a defense based on lack of intent.

However, claiming a lack of intent may not be enough to avoid a conviction. The defendant may need to provide evidence to support their claim, such as proof of a prior arrangement to borrow the item or evidence of an honest mistake.

Ownership or Permission

If a person charged with theft believed that they had a legal right to the property in question or had permission from the owner to take it, they may have a defense against the charges.

For example, if a person took an item from a store shelf, believing that they had already paid for it or that it was a free sample, they can argue that they had a good faith belief in their right to the property. Again, if someone borrowed an item from a friend or family member with their permission but later faced an accusation of theft, they may have a defense based on the owner’s consent.

However, the defendant must provide evidence supporting their ownership or permission claim. This may include receipts, witness testimony, or other documentation showing that they had a legal right to the property or that the owner had consented to their taking it.

Mistaken Identity

Again, mistaken identity can sometimes lead to wrongful accusations of theft against an individual. This can happen if the perpetrator resembles the accused or the witness’s memory is faulty.

Individuals who face theft charges due to mistaken identity can provide evidence of their innocence. This may include alibi evidence showing they were elsewhere during the theft or physical evidence such as surveillance footage or fingerprints that exclude them as suspects.

Entrapment

Entrapment is a defense that may be available to those induced by law enforcement to commit a crime they may not have otherwise committed. In theft cases, this may apply if a police officer or informant pressured or coerced the defendant into committing the theft.

For the entrapment defense to be successful, the defendant must show that the idea for the crime originated with the law enforcement agent and that the agent used persuasion or other means to induce the defendant to commit the crime. The defendant must also demonstrate their lack of predisposition to commit the crime before the agent’s participation.

Entrapment cases can be complex and difficult to prove and may require significant evidence and legal experience. The duress defense applies when the defendant shows that the threat was imminent and they reasonably believed someone would enforce the threat if they did not comply.

Duress

Duress is a defense that may be available to those forced to commit a crime, such as theft, under the threat of harm to themselves or others. The duress defense applies when the defendant demonstrates that the threat was imminent and that they reasonably believed the threat would occur if they did not comply.

For example, if a person was forced at gunpoint to steal money from a cash register, they can argue that they acted under duress and should not be held criminally responsible for the theft.

However, the duress defense is unavailable in all cases, and the defendant must provide evidence to support their claim. This may include witness testimony, physical evidence of the threat, or other documentation.

Those who believe they may have a duress defense should consult an experienced criminal defense attorney who can help them understand their legal options and build the strongest possible case.

The Importance of Legal Representation

Facing theft charges can be a daunting and stressful experience, and the consequences of a conviction can be severe. That is why having a skilled criminal defense lawyer is crucial. An experienced attorney can:

• Explain Your Rights: Your lawyer will ensure you understand your legal rights and options throughout the criminal justice process.
• Investigate Your Case: Your attorney will conduct a thorough investigation into the facts of your case, gathering evidence and interviewing witnesses to build a strong defense.
• Negotiate with Prosecutors: In some cases, your lawyer can negotiate with prosecutors to have your charges reduced or dismissed or to secure a more favorable plea bargain.
• Represent You in Court: If your case goes to trial, your criminal defense attorney will present your defense, cross-examine witnesses, and argue on your behalf before a judge and jury.
• Advocate for a Fair Sentence: If you are convicted, your lawyer will advocate for a fair and appropriate sentence, presenting mitigating factors and arguing for alternatives to incarceration when appropriate.

Contact a Criminal Defense Lawyer Today

Facing theft charges can be a frightening experience, and the possibility of going to jail is a serious concern for many defendants.

By understanding the charges against you, the potential penalties, and the defenses available, you can make informed decisions about your case and work with your defense attorney to achieve the best possible outcome. Remember, having a skilled criminal defense lawyer can make all the difference in protecting your rights and fighting for your freedom.

If you or a loved one is facing allegations of theft, don’t hesitate to seek legal representation. Contact an experienced criminal defense attorney today to discuss your case and learn more about how they can support you as you navigate the complex legal system and fight for your future.